Sorry, I mispoke. My apologies.
I consider the power cleans and power snatches to be dynamic movements. They have to be performed explosively (maximum speed) or they are useless. They also need to be performed at the very beginning of each session when you are your freshest.
I know that Louie and others have dynamic effort speed days with the exercises that you mention, but those movements aren't necessarily optimally performed at maximum speed. For example, yes you can bench press 500, but you are not going to move the barbell as fast as you would if your were moving 200.
With the cleans and the snatches, optimal speed must be attained when you get near optimal weights (240snatch/300+ clean) for you. Otherwise, you don't get the weight and no amount of strength is going to get it up. Some muscle snatches or muscle cleans can be performed by us "retard strong" folk, but even that has it's limits. As an asside, but highly related, My Coach is happy to see me moving weights I can't curl.
The inclusion of dynamic events (power clean and power snatch) would not take away form your power movements because the weights you would be moving would likely be 1/3 to 1/2 of what you can deadlift. That's a warm up.
That's the reason my sessions go from dynamic movement to absolute strength movements.
Again, my personal opinion is that you would not be properly served in including full squat cleans and full squat snatches into your training if your focus is powerlifting and highland games. The technical nuances of getting good at those movements requires countless #'s of repetitions and exposures to certain weights. Given that you only plan to do them one day a week, it really is not enough exposure to become technically proficient in those movements. I speak to that fact as I struggle with technique now that I'm nearing my limits in performing the movements based upon my physcial strength. Yes, they would, and are, fun to perform and move big weights, but given your goals, it doesn't add up. I've considered dumping them from my own training regiment, but given tht my sport is predicated upon timing and flawless execution, I decided to stay the course in order to maximize my own body mechanics. My thought was I needed to use my body in the most appropriate manner in order to put as much force behind the axe head as I could; the speed element comes into play when getting the axe out of the wood. The same holds true with the Olympic lifts in as much as you apply maximal force on the way up to get the bar off the ground, then maximal speed to get under the barbell to recieve it.
Force/Speed/Timing between the two.
Powerlifting is about maximal force - no speed. HG events have some events that are maximal strength like strongman. But some of the throwing events require the application as i've depicted it above.
personally, I would evaluate your events in HG - see which ones you are weak at, and train them more. If there is a relationship between Force/Speed then consider more gym movements that may have carryover to what you are requiring. (For example weight for height and throwing - power cleans and power snatches are perfect examples of exercises with dramatic carry over).
Just my thoughts and opinions.
all the best,
Originally Posted by Jason Brown
I am doing some dynamic effort stuff every workout (presses, bench, or box squat)
for speed strength. I am thinking adding some technique ( full clean and jerks and full snatches) reps into my warm up. My sport interest being divided between powerlifting and the highland events, I don't want to take away too much from my slow lifts.
Again thanks for the help,
BTW. I am 6'1"