I just got a Newsletter from the warrior diet guy.
Here's a section I thought was slightly flawed but also interesting: (quote's are his comments)
"You Need Your Carbs
Q: You've written that low-carb diets don't make sense because carbs are important for aspects of body chemistry. Yet all biochemical textbooks say that there's no physiological requirement for carbs because the gluconeogenesis process in the liver converts other substances, such as amino acids, glycerol and lactate, into glucose. In addition, low-carb diet advocates frequently mention that the body can run on intermediary by-products of fat metabolism called ketones, again making carb intake superfluous. How do you respond?
Ori: Let me say up front that muscles cannot convert protein or fat into glucose. According to all the biology texts, gluconeogenesis is a limited metabolic process, mostly restricted to the liver. Fast-twitch muscles depend mostly on glycolytic, or carb, fuel. In times of a desperate need for energy, such as during strength or speed training, gluconeogenesis may not be sufficient to provide critical glucose to the working muscles. Furthermore, when carbs are severely restricted and the demand for energy increases, the body would be forced to shut down one of its most critically important hepatic metabolic pathways. That pathway regulates the production of DNA, RNA, nucleic acid material, energy molecules and several potent antioxidant compounds.
Known as the pentose phosphate pathway (PPP), it's completely dependent on an adequate glucose supply. With severe carb restriction, when insufficient glucose is available, the body turns off the PPP and switches to a sheer energy-producing process. When that occurs, the body may adversely compromise its capacity for promoting anabolic and immuno-enhancing activity. So you decrease your ability to recuperate and build muscle.
Athletes can't permit themselves to be in such a compromised state. Carbs are essential for active individuals. They also play a critical role in post-exercise recovery. Without carbs and their related insulin spikes there's no final activation of such anabolic hormones as IGF-1 and growth hormone after exercise.
Protein is the worst fuel source. Its breakdown results in metabolic waste substances, such as nitrites and nitrates, which adversely affect nitric oxide synthesis. That, in turn, suppresses vasodilation and muscle capacity for performance and for resisting fatigue.
As for ketones, they're acids that, when produced in abundance - for example, during low-carb diets - inhibit fat breakdown and elevate cortisol levels, as the body desperately tries to increase blood sugar and lower acidity levels. The increased acidity that ketones produce also forces the body to leech alkalizing minerals, such as calcium, from bones and other lean tissues. Contrary to popular belief, ketosis is a substantially catabolic process that leads to adverse effects in those seeking added lean mass.
Finally, scientists now believe that physical activity is programmed into the human genome. Carb food, essential for physical activity, is also essential for the human body. It's a potent carrier of essential nutrients, including proteoglucan and immuno-boosting nutrients. Biologically, low-carb diets just don't make sense, especially for active people engaged in exercise and sports."
“Our doubts are traitors,
And make us lose the good we oft might win,
By fearing to attempt.”
-William Shakespeare, Measure for Measure