Why do coaches still teach the thigh bump? Why was/is it thought to be acceptable technique?
Something about it just boggles my mind because a former coach kept telling me literally bring my hips into the bar to hit it. All I got out of that was some bruising, lots of pain, and the ability to jump forward a foot and still snatch decent weights.
Also because of that stint with this coach I tend to bang the bar off my hips 1 out of 5 lifts, not necessarily knocking it forward but in an attempt to keep the bar close.
I could be totally wrong, and people may disagree, but I say ignore everything about "thigh bumping". Maybe that works for people who do kettlebell swings, but not for those who snatch and clean & jerk.
I think there are 2 reasons - One, it's a style of lifting that has worked for a select few lifters (primarily of the very short variety), but much more often I think it's simply a misunderstanding of what's happening during lifts by very explosive lifters. In other words, it appears that they're banging it against their hips/thighs because they're moving so violently and change directions so abruptly.
Yes, it should touch your thighs - slide up them more like. Below the knees, the bar doesn't need to be in contact... but it should be extremely close if it's not. Once you pass the knees, it really needs to come in, and by the time it reaches mid-thigh, it sjhould be sliding up the thighs (not dragging).
Ok, thanks Greg. I'll have someone watch and tell me if there is contact and if so, good...then I can stop trying to get a conscious bump. And if not, I'll problem-solve it a little (by referencing your book primarily).
I'd agree with Greg. This question comes up every time we run a coaching course because to most people it does look like the bar bounces off the thighs when a good lifter is doing it.
we always describe it to our lifters as the "thigh brush" and also explain that the bar touching the thighs during the second pull is a CONSEQUENCE of good technique (keeping the bar close) not the goal in itself.