Originally Posted by Jamie J. Skibicki
"Even episode one was tollerable when he was on screen"
You give it much to high a rating.
Fair enough. How about when Liam Neeson was on screen and jar jar, and young anikan were not on screen the movie was tolerable.
basically I thought Liam's character and Obi Wan were cool and the final lightsaber battle was awesome. Most the rest made me want to gouge my eyeballs out... after murdering George Lucas.
Originally Posted by Chris Rice
If you haven't already - read Ender's Game - I think it might make a neat movie also.
One of my all time favorite books. And I loved the series, Speaker for the Dead, Xynocide, and Children of the Mind were awesome. Wasn't as much a fan of the shadow books, the first was ok but the rest just seemed forced to me and focused too much on being "action packed" which is not Orson Scott Card's style, at least not the couple of series I have read of his.